Environmentally-friendly Packaging | Which is Best?

Recent years have seen plastic become the villain of the food packaging world, with many companies suddenly switching to paper, glass or new ‘biodegradable’ materials instead. But how can we be sure that – from an environmental perspective – this is the right decision? How should we compare one material against another?

To answer this question, researchers use a technique called Life Cycle Analysis (LCA). “In a nutshell, a LCA assesses all the environmental impacts for the materials, resources and emissions associated with a product’s complete lifecycle, including extracting the materials, manufacturing, transport, the use phase and the end of its life,” says Dr Rukayya Ibrahim Muazu, a chemical-environmental engineer at the University of Sheffield. LCAs are highly rigorous, governed by an international standard,1 and generally done by practiced experts. 

Comparing Different Packaging Types

A good LCA will consider a wide range of environmental impacts, including carbon emissions, energy consumption, land and water use, toxic chemicals, and of course, what happens to the material at the end of its life. But even when done properly, an LCA can only give us an approximation or a range for a material’s impact because it will depend on exactly how individual pieces of packaging are produced, used and disposed of. 

For example, an LCA of a packaging material might consider the energy used to produce it (was it sourced from renewables, or fossil fuels?), where the raw materials come from (does it contain any recycled content? For paper, was the wood harvested from sustainably-managed forests?), how heavy it is and how it’s transported around the world (by land, sea or air?), how easily can it be recycled or reused (does it contain special food-safe coatings that prevent recycling?), and whether that recycling process uses energy or produces wastewater or toxic chemicals. LCAs taking a broader view might also consider social issues, such as whether production involved unfair pay for workers, or forced or child labour. 

Context is key

One issue with LCAs is that they can be very reductionist. As the table above shows, every type of packaging has both good and bad features. For instance, despite the recent backlash against single-use plastic, it has proved immeasurably useful during the COVID-19 pandemic for producing PPE, protective screens and vaccine syringes. The most environmentally-friendly packaging for one context won’t be the same as for another. 

Consider glass as an example. Certain brands of yogurts and chilled desserts have switched from plastic to glass because glass is often seen as being ‘better for the environment.’ But whilst glass can be recycled indefinitely, transporting and remelting it have high associated carbon emissions. It’s why Santiago Navarro, CEO & Co-Founder of Garçon Wines2 decided to launch a new type of wine bottle for his business; flat bottles made from recycled PET plastic. “Our flat bottles pack like books, meaning we can fit up to 91% more wine on the same transport pallet compared with using round, glass bottles. Combined with the lightweight nature of PET, this reduces the carbon emissions of our bottles by approximately 50%, according to two LCAs conducted by third parties on our bottles,” he says.

However, in a closed-loop or deposit-return system, such as a milk delivery round, glass containers may be the best option, since they can be washed and reused directly for the same purpose many times. In such a system, it's thought that glass milk bottles have a lower carbon footprint than single-use plastic bottles after being reused just 20 times.3 Similarly, more durable containers can also be the lowest-impact option for new home-delivery subscription services, such as TerraCycle’s Loop, where they can be simply washed and reused many times over.

Sometimes single-use is the best

But whilst it’s easy to reuse containers in some situations, in others reusing or recycling food packaging is much more difficult. In these cases, single-use, disposable packaging may actually be - counterintuitively - the most environmentally-friendly option. 

For instance, an LCA study4 which compared different single-use takeaway boxes concluded that, across all 18 environmental impact categories assessed, non-recyclable Styrofoam containers had a much lower total impact than recyclable plastic or aluminium containers. “Because expanded polystyrene (EPS) containers have low density (Styrofoam can be more than 95% air), they don’t require much material” lead author Dr Alejandro Gallego-Schmid from the University of Manchester explains. “We found that, depending on the impact category, you would have to reuse a Tupperware container between 16 and 208 times, until it became a better environmental option than EPS - and when it comes to terrestrial ecotoxicity, reusing Tupperware is often actually a worse choice because of the chemicals involved in washing the container and the electricity required to heat the water.”

Nevertheless, there are other issues with single-use, disposable takeaway containers - including a high propensity to be littered and the pollution of ocean ecosystems with microplastics - which are not always included in or well considered by LCAs. Perhaps the ideal solution would be for the takeaway food industry to be designed with reuse in mind, so that containers could be used hundreds of times over and washed in bulk (using non-toxic detergents) to minimise their environmental impact. Pilot schemes (such as Fresh Bowl in NYC, which encourages customers to return their reusable glass jars in return for free credit) show it may be possible, but doing this on a large scale will require considerable investment, as well as national policies that all stakeholders - including packaging producers, consumers and retailers- can commit to. 

Designing better systems

Clearly, to reduce packaging waste without causing even more damage to our environment, we have to consider more than just the materials we are using. If we want reusing packaging to be the most environmentally-friendly option every time, we need to optimise entire systems, taking into account waste management infrastructures and human behaviour. 

Though plastic pollution remains a major issue, plastic itself is not intrinsically evil - indeed, plastic packaging can play an important role in reducing food loss, particularly for perishable products such as salads and some vegetables. In an ideal system, it's likely that every packaging type will have a role to play. To achieve this, we’ll have to shift away from over-generalising and be prepared to embrace different packaging types - perhaps even single-use plastic - when the evidence shows it makes the most environmental sense.

Most viewed

Inside Our Food

Why are some egg yolks so orange?

Annabel Slater

Does egg yolk colour matter? And why are yolks from different countries different colours?

Human Stories

Tomatoes in Italy: The Social Cost of Production

Silvia Lazzaris

Tomatoes are a staple ingredient in many homes across Europe, but the story of how they reach your…

Earth First

How to Eat Edible Flowers

Virginie Maenhout

Do you also get hyped when discovering glossy flowers mixed into your fresh salad? Or do you feel…

Human Stories

Agro Robots | Which Robots Actually Work On Farms?

Annabel Slater

Harvesting fruit and vegetables is repetitive and arduous. The human workforce is dwindling due to…

Earth First

The Surprising Sources of Protein That Are Not Animal Products

Kelly Oakes

Just because you don’t eat meat, doesn’t mean you have to miss out on protein. In fact,…

History & Culture

La Tomatina Festival | A Photo-Essay

Cait Mack

Each year on the last Wednesday of August, crowds descend on the sleepy mediaeval town of Buñol in…

Earth First

Health Claims | FAQs

Dr Stacey Lockyer

What are health claims and how are they regulated in Europe? Read on to find answers to your FAQs.

History & Culture

Desert Locust Plague 2020: A Threat to Food Security

Molly Melvin

Countries across East Africa have been hit with the worst locust plague the region has seen in…

Inside Our Food

Dehydrating Food | How It Works

Keeren Flora

Dehydration is one of the world’s oldest methods of food preservation, with the principles of…

Earth First

How Do Food Businesses Manage Food Waste?

Madhura Rao

Food can end up as waste before it reaches us for several reasons, whether it’s safety…

Inside Our Food

How Yogurt Is Made | Ask The Expert

Carolina Moyano ,Silvia Lazzaris

Ever wondered how yogurt is made? Here at FoodUnfolded, we wanted to know not only how yogurt is…

What Is Vegan “Cheese”?

Samanta Oon

Vegan alternatives to cheese haven’t always measured up to the oozy, melty, rich goodness of…

Keep updated with the latest news about your food with our newsletter

Follow Us