Facebook
header-banner-biodiversity-protein_1.webp

Protein & Biodiversity | How 5 Common Protein Sources Affect Biodiversity

Our choice of protein – whether we eat animal products or eschew them in favour of plant-based sources – can have a big impact on the environment. But it’s not just water use and carbon emissions we should be worried about. Find out how the food we eat affects biodiversity.

What is biodiversity?

biodiversity wild flowers field

Biodiversity is the variety of plant and animal life in a particular environment, whether in a pristine natural forest or a farmer’s field. As well as having intrinsic value, a subset of this biodiversity contributes to the food we grow, from bees that pollinate orchards to microbes that keep the soil fertile. Farming practices like irrigation, pesticides and fertilisers, and introducing new crop varieties can all affect biodiversity.

A report published by the Food and Agriculture Organisation of the UN earlier this year said that the biodiversity that supports our food production is under threat.1 And we’re already seeing the impacts of the loss: over the last two decades, around 20% of the earth’s vegetated surface has become less productive. 
 

Here’s how five protein sources impact biodiversity:

1. Beef, Pork, and Poultry Based Protein

red meat

If you’ve only heard of one problem relating to food production and biodiversity, it’s likely to be deforestation to make space for cattle in the Amazon rainforest – with demand for beef driving the practice.4

But it’s not just land cleared for the animals themselves that is the problem. Growing soybeans for animal feed results in the loss of habitats for many species, including endangered ones like the black-faced lion tamarin, which lives in forests in Brazil.2

Brazil is one of the largest producers and exporters of pork and poultry worldwide.2 To make enough feed for all of those animals, it is also the second largest grower of soybeans, after the US.3

While efforts to preserve the Amazon by restricting soybean growth are ongoing, other habitats are less protected. The Cerrado, a tropical savannah region which is home to a variety of wildlife and hosts an aquifer that supplies water to the Amazon river – was home to more than 60% of the soybeans grown in Brazil during 2012-13.3

When it comes to farms themselves, not all are created equal in terms of their impacts on biodiversity. Clearing land for cattle grazing has a negative effect on biodiversity, for example – but there are measures farmers can take to make their farms more wildlife friendly. Keeping existing trees and shrubs, or planting new ones as part of a pasture in what’s known as a ‘silvopastoral’ system, can provide a home for many varieties of birds and insects while helping retain soil structure, and giving the farm animals themselves a better quality of life.10

2. Dairy and Egg Based Protein

Dairy products

It’s not just animals raised for meat that contribute to habitat destruction from soy farming. Many dairy cattle are also raised on soy-based feed. France, for example, imports over 60% of its soy meal from Brazil, meaning that French Camembert, and the milk on your morning cereal, could also have played a part in reducing biodiversity on the other side of the world.12

Some dairy farmers choose to avoid soy-based cattle feed, or go as far as only to feed their cattle on grass, avoiding grain-based feed entirely. In the UK, for example, the “Pasture for Life” certification marks milk from cows only fed on pasture.11

Milk and eggs are, however, a more efficient way to produce protein-heavy food than meat. For every 100 grams of protein that we feed to animals in the form of grain, we get, on average,  about 43 grams of protein in milk, 35 in eggs, 40 in chicken, 10 in pork, or 5 in beef.5 What an animal is fed does have an impact on how much food they produce – for example, cows that graze on silvopasture (with trees and shrubs) produce more milk and, therefore, more protein than cows fed on grass pasture or grain.10

3. Tofu Based Protein

Tofu

Tofu is made by coagulating soy milk, made from soy beans, so the biodiversity problems associated with soy farming can apply to tofu, too. However, the environmental impact per kilogram of protein is less if you consume tofu made directly from soybeans rather than meat from animals fed with soy.

Of course, not all soy farming involves deforestation. The Roundtable on Responsible Soy has developed criteria for responsible soy production and allows producers to get certified to prove they meet standards.13

4. Shrimp Based Protein

Shrimp

To farm shrimp for food, some coastal lowlands in the US and Asia have been turned into shrimp ponds. This has resulted in the loss of habitats like salt marshes and mangroves.

Shrimp farms in China, for instance, which mainly produce shrimp exports for the US, EU, and Japan, often discharge wastewater to the surrounding environment.6 Nutrients in this water can result in algal blooms for nearby waterways. Algal blooms can be toxic to fish, other plants and animals, and can build up in the food chain. The blooms also consume oxygen as they decompose, stopping seafloor dwellers like crabs and clams from getting enough and blocking essential sunlight needed for aquatic plant life.7

5. Nut Based Protein

Nuts

Water use is one of the biggest environmental concerns when it comes to growing nuts. California, US, produces around 80% of the world’s almonds, and in 2011 experienced an extreme drought lasting five years. Though almonds were not entirely to blame for the overuse of water in the state (alfalfa, a crop mostly grown for animal feed, also contributed), many believe they played a big part.8 During the drought, 129 million trees died – more than would usually be expected over that period. 9 When trees are lost, so is the shade they provide to wildlife that lives in the forest.

Water loss in California also threatens Aquatic species and habitats, and the five-year drought brought several fish species closer to extinction.14

But there are more responsible ways to produce nuts. Read more about the sustainability of Brazil nuts here.

Keep updated with the latest news about your food with our newsletter.

Subscribe

Most viewed

History & Culture

Underground Mushroom Farms | A Visual Essay

Eloise Adler

47 million years ago, when the sea covered the north of France, limestone banks started to form in…

History & Culture

Quarantine Stories: Shanat, UK

Katharina Kropshofer

Even though the lockdown situation is different in every European country, we all had to adapt our…

Inside Our Food

What’s the Difference Between Probiotics and Prebiotics?

Lydia Melville

Our bodies contain just as many microbial cells as human cells, if not more - and most of these…

Earth First

Beauty Products Made From Food Waste

David Urry, Anna Brightman

A lot of food waste, like coffee grounds, fruit stones and eggshells, is inedible. Find out how we…

The Future

Holy cow! Beef without cows?

Luke Cridland, Meghan Horvath

Did you know that scientists have found a way to grow meat in a lab? It may sound crazy, but…

Human Stories

Cocoa, Coffee, and Cocaine: A Bitter-Sweet Future for Farmers in Colombia

Sunny Chen

Coca, once used in the original Coca-Cola recipe in 1886, has impacted Colombia since the industry…

The Future

Seaweed Farming: Silver Bullet or Something Else?

Bonnie Waycott

Seaweeds have become increasingly popular in recent years. As more eyes are drawn to farming them,…

The Future

The Regulatory Minefield of Novel Foods

Lauren Lewis

Novel foods like cultivated meat, insects and microbial protein could become future staples to help…

Earth First

4 Surprising Foods That Have More Calcium Than Milk

Kelly Oakes

Milk and dairy products are a good source of calcium; but they're not the only way to meet your…

Earth First

Trace Your Food Back to its Source

Marie Lödige

Do you ever wonder where your food comes from? An apple in your local supermarket might have come…

Inside Our Food

Why are some egg yolks so orange?

Annabel Slater

Does egg yolk colour matter? And why are yolks from different countries different colours?

Inside Our Food

Animal Testing in Food Research | Ask the Expert

Madhura Rao, Dr Alie de Boer

It might come as a surprise, but some foods or ingredients are tested on animals. Moving away from…

References See MoreSee Less

Keep updated with the latest news about your food with our newsletter

Subscribe

Follow Us