Facebook
Article_Banner_SeafoodFraud.webp
Earth First

Seafood Fraud in The Supply Chain

It might be easy to recognise a chicken from a pigeon, but it’s not that easy when it comes to distinguishing haddock from cod fillet. And that’s one reason why fish is one of the products most commonly affected by food fraud, together with olive oil, milk, honey, saffron, wine and vanilla extract.

How often is our seafood mislabelled?

Several analyses and studies have proven that a huge percentage of fish is mislabelled.1 An analysis of ‘king scallops’ in a German market revealed that 48% of the tested samples revealed to be the less prestigious Japanese scallop.2 A similar analysis conducted on shark fillets from Italian fish markets and fishmongers found that 45% of the sharks were mislabelled, with cheaper species being sold as the preferred ones.3
 

A Guardian Seascape analysis of 44 studies, looking at more than 9000 seafood samples from various actors in the food chain, such as restaurants, fishmongers and supermarkets across 30 countries, found that 36% of seafood was mislabelled.4

A Guardian Seascape analysis found that 36% of seafood across 30 countries was mislabelled.

A Guardian Seascape analysis found that 36% of seafood across 30 countries was mislabelled.

Is mislabelling a widespread phenomenon?

Giving precise estimates is hard. Studies are often conducted on specific target species and use different samples and methodologies – and this makes it hard to draw general conclusions. However, the numbers from different studies consistently prove that seafood mislabelling is a widespread phenomenon.

The first large-scale attempt to study the rate of fish mislabelling in the mass catering sector (restaurants, canteens, schools, hospitals) across Europe was conducted in 2018 and found that 26% of the samples were mislabelled. The highest mislabelling rate was observed in Spain, Iceland, Finland and Germany, where close to half of the outlets offered mislabelled food.1

Average mislabelling by region graphic

Why seafood mislabelling or fraud happens
 

There are various reasons for mislabelling. In some cases, it might just be that the long, complex, international supply chains make it hard to trace food, which increases the likelihood of mistakes - the longer the food chain, the higher the vulnerability. But oftentimes, the opaqueness of the system is intentionally used to one’s advantage. There is a huge economic incentive to pass a lower-value fish as a more popular one. The lack of traceability also makes it easy to get away with.4

Fraud often happens in the shape of fish laundering, which is the concealment of the illegal origins of seafood. For example, fish may have been caught where fishing – or fishing that particular endangered species – was banned. Fish laundering is mostly linked to unreported and unregulated catches by large fleets operating off the coasts of Africa, Asia and South America.

What can be done?

Combating fish fraud will be hard, but third-party verification, stronger regulation, and digital traceability methods will be fundamental in tackling it. On top of this, the WWF set up six principles that should be the foundation of a framework of traceability:5
 

  1. The essential information (who, what, when, how) regarding a caught fish should be available and displayed.
  2. Full chain traceability should be implemented to monitor each stage along the chain.
  3. Effective tracking of product transformation should provide information about where and how the product was transformed.
  4. Digital information and standardised data formats should be used to ensure proper tracking.
  5. Verification from the government or third parties should happen consistently and regularly.
  6. Transparency and public access to information should give everyone the tools to make conscious decisions.

Keep updated with the latest news about your food with our newsletter.

Subscribe

Related articles

Most viewed

Earth First

Figs & Wasps | How are Figs Pollinated?

Molly Melvin

If you're anything like me, you've probably given little thought to figs - aside from how delicious…

Earth First

The Brazil Nut | How It’s Grown

Molly Melvin

At first glance, the Brazil nut seems little more than an oversized, overpriced nut you pass in the…

Earth First

Insect Farming | How Insects Help Reduce Food Waste

Jane Alice Liu, Miha Pipan

When you think about bugs, you might think of the alarming drop in insect populations that we are…

Human Stories

The Unequal Costs of Going Organic

Laura Tresso

Buying organic food can reassure consumers about the origins of their food. But the price and…

Earth First

Plant-Based Diets and Diabetes

Alexandra Alcorta

The prevalence of diabetes has been increasing over the past few decades. In 2019, about 463 million…

Earth First

Do Plant-based Diets Provide Enough Protein?

Klaus Hadwiger, Angelika Schulz

We've all heard the argument that plant-based diets don't provide us with enough protein - but is it…

Earth First

4 Ways To Prevent Food Waste

Annabel Slater

42% of food wastage in Europe occurs in households, with homes in the UK, Germany, and the…

Earth First

Quinoa | A Climate Proof Food

Merel Deelder

Due to the effects of climate change, producing enough food for our growing world population is…

Human Stories

Farmed Fish | The ASC Certification Label | Buying Sustainable Aquaculture

Jessica Tengvall

Have you ever spotted a light green ASC label on various seafood products? The ASC label manages…

Human Stories

Black Tea: The Social Cost of Assam Tea

Madhura Rao

Its deep, malty flavour makes it popular among tea connoisseurs around the world. Its status as an…

Earth First

Plastic Alternatives: Start-Up Challenges

Claudia Parms

The European Parliament officially announced this year that non-essential single-use plastics will…

Earth First

Ethical Food Choices | Opinion

Lottie Bingham

Despite being free from any food intolerances or allergies, there are a number of dietary…

Keep updated with the latest news about your food with our newsletter

Subscribe

Follow Us