Fishing Gear, What’s More Sustainable?

If you're from a Scandinavian country like me, you might eat fish once a week; maybe even more. You probably know that fish can be cultivated on farms or caught in the wild. But do you know about the methods and tools used to get fish from the ocean to your plate? Read on to find out about common fishing techniques in Europe, and how they impact the environment.

All fishing techniques affect the environment to some extent. Damage to the sea bed can destroy precious habitats, and unwanted species are frequently caught as by-catch.  But when it comes to fishing, some techniques are more harmful than others.

3 Common Fishing Techniques in Europe

The European Commission has grouped the different gears according to three major fishing techniques depending on how they are used. In the EU, fishing techniques are classified under three gear groups:1

1. Towed gear

Towed gear literally drags a net “bag” across the bottom of the ocean floor. We typically call this gear trawls and dredges. These are used for capturing bottom-dwelling sea life (e.g. flatfish, mussels, and some cod species), which is why the net has to be in contact with the ocean floor. Essentially, fishermen are “towing” their catch. 

2. Mobile gear

Types of mobile gears include seines, longlines and trolling lines (which are either nets or lines with hooks). Unlike towed gear, mobile gear is not actively towed, although it involves the movement of the fishing vessel. Mobile gear is usually used in the open water column. Techniques like these are effective for schooling fish species like sardines, herring or mackerel.

3. Passive gear

 Passive gear (e.g. gill nets, trammel nets, traps, longlines) use traps, nets or lines with hooks anchored or left to drift in the water. This technique is widely used in European waters. Essentially, this technique passively catches fish rather than actively drawing them in.

But how do each of these techniques impact the environment? Scroll through the galleries below to find out.

Gear impact on the environment


Towed Gear

Mobile Gear

Passive Gear

So, which fishing gears have the highest environmental impact?

Well actually, there is no complete consensus on this, as different gears affect the environment in different ways. But, the gear with the highest habitat impact are dredges and demersal trawls. They have more by-catch, especially trawls, since they are the least species- and size-selective gear. The more sustainable gear to look for are traps and lines.

It is also important to understand that as long as we want to eat certain species of fish or seafood, some fishing techniques are unavoidable. You cannot, for example, catch flatfish with passive or mobile gear—at least not yet.

So when buying fish, the most sustainable fish choice is to go for open-water living species because the gear used to catch them seem to only be impacting vulnerable species caught as by-catch and not habitat on top.

The bottom line

While no techniques have zero impact (at least not yet), some gears have more sustainable methods than others. So do not give up hope on your search for sustainable choices for fish-eating! Scientists and fishermen are working hard together to create innovative fishing gear to try and overcome these impacts.

For now, you can look for MSC (Marine Stewardship Council) markings on packaging as guidance to more sustainable fish. There are also several websites where you can look up a fish species to see if it is sustainably fished. Different websites have different criteria, but most are based on how they are fished, where and if the fish stock is healthy (and not declining). Take a look at seafoodwatch.org and eumofa.eu, as both have detailed descriptions of various fish species. 

Related articles

Most viewed

History & Culture

Quarantine Stories: Notina, Greece

Katharina Kropshofer

Even though the lockdown situation is different in every European country, we all had to adapt our…

The Future

7 Alternative Ways To Grow Food and Community

Aran Shaunak

Over the course of generations, farms have become bigger, more industrialised and more efficient.…

Inside Our Food

Why are some egg yolks so orange?

Annabel Slater

Does egg yolk colour matter? And why are yolks from different countries different colours?

History & Culture

Garam Masala | Origin of Indian Spices

Nandini Tengvall

Many Westerners only know the generic British term "curry", but there's so much more to Indian…

Earth First

Seed Banks - Safeguarding Biodiversity | A Visual Essay

Eloise Adler

Take a look inside the seed banks protecting the world’s biodiversity and safeguarding our future.

The Future

The Regulatory Minefield of Novel Foods

Lauren Lewis

Novel foods like cultivated meat, insects and microbial protein could become future staples to help…

Human Stories

Cocoa, Coffee, and Cocaine: A Bitter-Sweet Future for Farmers in Colombia

Sunny Chen

Coca, once used in the original Coca-Cola recipe in 1886, has impacted Colombia since the industry…

Earth First

The Cost of Food Waste

David Urry

Changing everyday choices around food is central to tackling food waste, especially in wealthier…

Earth First

Ethical Food Choices | Opinion

Lottie Bingham

Despite being free from any food intolerances or allergies, there are a number of dietary…

Earth First

Oat Milk | How It’s Made

Inés Oort Alonso

If you have ever had a go at making oat milk at home, you might have found some stark differences…

The Future

Cultured Meat: Better Than The Real Thing?

Lottie Bingham

Some 60+ start-ups across the globe claim that they will soon be selling cultured meat grown in a…

Human Stories

Food and Place | Does Where You Live Influence Your Eating Habits?

Luke Cridland

Where food is sold is not decided randomly, and many factors go into determining where you can buy…

Keep updated with the latest news about your food with our newsletter

Follow Us